Court Sentences Security Guard To Death For Killing Man In Enugu
Justice Okpe held that the defendant's two confessional statements to the police, alongside other evidence, established his guilt
An Enugu State High Court has sentenced a security guard, Shuaibu Mohammed, to death by hanging for stabbing a man, Njoku Nwabueze, to death during a disagreement at Soil Plaza, Emene, Enugu.
Justice Kenneth Okpe, who delivered the judgment on Wednesday, convicted Mohammed of murder, ruling that the prosecution had proved the charge beyond reasonable doubt.
The court heard that the incident occurred on October 1, 2021, following a disagreement between the defendant and the deceased over an alleged theft at the plaza where Mohammed worked as a security guard.
In his judgment, Justice Okpe held that the defendant's two confessional statements to the police, alongside other evidence, established his guilt.
The judge noted that Mohammed had admitted stabbing Nwabueze with a dagger at the back of the left side of his chest during the altercation.
He observed that although the defendant denied the allegation while testifying in court, he failed to retract or explain the two confessional statements in his written deposition.
According to the judge, the statements, made before two different police officers at separate locations and on different days, were consistent in their material details.
Justice Okpe dismissed the defence argument that the statements were inadmissible because they were not video-recorded or made in the presence of the defendant's lawyer, as provided under Section 17 of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law of Enugu State, 2017.
He held that there was no evidence that Mohammed was tortured, threatened or forced to make the statements.
The judge also rejected the defence of provocation and self-defence, ruling that stabbing the deceased with a dagger was disproportionate to the alleged provocation.
On self-defence, he said evidence before the court showed that Nwabueze was stabbed in the back, indicating that he was no longer facing the defendant when the fatal attack occurred.
Justice Okpe further identified Mohammed's abandonment of his duty post and subsequent flight to Eke Obinagu after the incident as part of the circumstantial evidence against him.
He explained that the prosecution did not need to produce an eyewitness to establish murder, as a conviction could be secured through confessional statements, circumstantial evidence or direct evidence.
The court consequently held that the prosecution had established the three ingredients of murder: that the deceased died, that his death resulted from the defendant's unlawful act, and that the act was intentional.
During allocutus, defence counsel, C. C. Azubuike, pleaded for mercy, while the prosecution, led by C. N. Avah, a Director in the Enugu State Ministry of Justice, confirmed that the defendant had no previous criminal conviction.
However, the judge said he had no discretion to impose a lesser sentence because Section 274(1) of the Criminal Code Law of Enugu State prescribes death for murder.
He subsequently sentenced Mohammed to death by hanging, adding, "May God have mercy on his soul."
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Angry
0
Sad
0
Wow
0

